Fayetteville passes ban on canine and cat gross sales at puppy shops

Justine Lentz, the town’s animal services and products superintendent, speaks on the Town Council agenda-setting consultation on July 12, 2022. (Fayetteville Govt Channel)

A brand new Fayetteville regulation objectives to make sure the town doesn’t facilitate the sale of animals raised in large-scale, industrial breeding amenities.

Town Council individuals on Tuesday voted unanimously to approve a suggestion that prohibits the retail sale of canine and cats except they’re first bought from and in cooperation with the town’s animal refuge or any other animal rescue group.

Whilst there are these days no puppy shops in Fayetteville that promote canine or cats, town body of workers stated the objective is to forestall any long term shops from promoting pets that could be raised in inhumane stipulations.

Fayetteville’s two biggest puppy shops – Petco and Petsmart – have company mandates in opposition to the sale of canine and cats. And whilst other people can every so often undertake animals from the ones shops, the pets are made to be had along with native animal shelters or animal welfare companies.

Justine Lentz, the town’s animal services and products superintendent, stated the speculation of a ban used to be first mentioned via the town’s Animal Products and services Advisory Board after a Petland puppy retailer franchise that has been accused of promoting doggies from large-scale breeders opened a brand new location in Rogers in 2019.

For the reason that retailer has opened, Lentz stated it’s been related to backlash from shoppers who stated they bought ill doggies with all kinds of well being problems from critical worms to Parvo.

Lentz instructed the council she sought after to behave temporarily after not too long ago listening to a couple of new Petland retailer coming to the town.

“We did get wind that possibly someone used to be fascinated with opening such an established order right here, and we would have liked to get forward of that,” stated Lentz.

An indication for a brand new Petland retailer used to be not too long ago put in at 637 E. Joyce Blvd. subsequent to Newk’s Eatery in north Fayetteville, and a staff used to be observed Tuesday cleansing and getting ready the brand new house.

A staff works to organize for the outlet of a brand new Petland retailer at 637 E. Joyce Blvd. subsequent to Newk’s Eatery in north Fayetteville. (Photograph via Sarah Gill)

Lentz instructed the council her division has observed a number of animals come throughout the refuge that had been raised in wide amenities – continuously known as pet generators – the place the well being of animals is continuously brushed aside so as to handle a low overhead and maximize income.

“For those who’re no longer aware of a pet mill, rely your self fortunate,” Lentz stated. “The stipulations discovered there are generally lovely deplorable.”

Animals raised in the ones stipulations, she stated, continuously have well being issues and an inherent concern of people as a result of they’re usually handled like farm animals.

Lentz stated the animal services and products board researched and mentioned the proposal, and in the end voted in want of recommending that the council institute a ban at the retail sale of canine and cats. She stated within the board’s analysis, the crowd didn’t uncover any bans in Arkansas, however did to find identical regulation in additional than 300 towns in 26 states around the nation, together with a brand new regulation that used to be handed in Dallas, Texas in Would possibly.

“We’re no longer trailblazing right here, however I feel we’re undoubtedly surroundings a excellent instance,” Lentz stated.

The brand new regulation gained’t have any impact on small-scale, non-retail breeders on the town.

“For those who’re breeding in an overly small operation, like possibly you could have a few canine and you need to reproduce them to your yard and also you’re accountable about it, the town is okay with that,” Lentz stated.

Right through public remark, a number of citizens spoke in want of the proposal. One couple who spoke stated they’d a super enjoy with a pet they purchased at Petland.

Karen Barker, a consultant for Petland Inc., stated the dad or mum corporate does its easiest to ensure the doggies offered at its franchises get a variety of interplay with people prior to being offered.

“We have now procedures and protocols in position,” Barker stated. “We’re at all times that specialize in the only precedence, which is the well being and happiness of the doggies whilst they’re on the retailer.”

Barker stated to ensure that a breeder to promote a pet to a puppy retailer, they need to be approved and controlled via the US Division of Agriculture.

“I’ve visited masses of our breeders, all who’re approved via the USDA,” Barker stated.

Samantha Boyle, who owns a Petland franchise with shops in Joplin, Missouri and Rogers, stated she hopes to quickly open the brand new Fayetteville retailer.

Boyle stated the claims about her Rogers retailer had been unsubstantiated. She stated she is aware of for a incontrovertible fact that not one of the breeders she’s ever labored with could be thought to be pet generators.

“A large number of the breeders we use are households identical to you,” she instructed the council.

Ryan and Samantha Boyle, homeowners of a neighborhood Petland franchise, discuss on the Town Council assembly on July 19, 2022. (Fayetteville Govt Channel)

Steve Clark, president of the Fayetteville Chamber of Trade, stated the council may well be overstepping its obstacles via looking to keep watch over what will also be introduced in line with the style by which it’s being introduced reasonably than its legality.

Town Legal professional Equipment Williams stated this wouldn’t be the primary time the council has put rules at the sale of canine or cats. He stated the town as soon as allowed pets to be offered in parking rather a lot, however that’s now not the case.

Clark stated he used to be additionally discouraged to listen to that the brand new Petland retailer in Fayetteville has gotten thru just about the entire processes required to open and is now dealing with a possible new law.

Councilmember Teresa Turk requested if the ordinance may well be held for a couple of weeks to permit the Petland homeowners a while to speak with the town’s animal services and products division about their explicit practices and prototcols.

Councilmember Sloan Scroggin stated without reference to when a choice is made, it must be unbiased of the brand new Petland retailer.

“I think like it will’t be about Petland,” Scroggin stated. “It must be about whether or not we would like a undeniable form of industry prohibited or no longer.”

Councilmember Mark Kinion agreed, and stated whilst the native Petland franchise homeowners would possibly run a blank store, that doesn’t imply different shops gained’t act in some way that facilitates large-scale breeders.

Councilmember Holly Hertzberg, who co-sponsored the measure in conjunction with Councilmember Sarah Bunch, stated she used to be able to decide right away.

“For me, this isn’t to do with any specific industry,” Hertzberg stated. “That is in regards to the care of animals.”

Hertzberg moved to ship the ordinance to the 3rd and ultimate studying, and Bunch seconded. That movement handed 5-2 with Scroggin and Turk balloting in opposition to.

Within the ultimate determination, the council voted 8-0 to approve the measure.

Tuesday’s proposal got here with an hooked up emergency clause movement that may’ve put the brand new regulation into fast impact as a substitute of the usual 30-day prolong, however the movement failed after Kinion, Turk, Scroggin and Councilmember Mike Wiederkehr voted in opposition to. An emergency clause calls for a supermajority to cross.

Prior to the vote, Mayor Lioneld Jordan stated had it come all the way down to a tie, he would’ve voted to strengthen the proposal.

“I imagine that this sort of ordinance must be handed, no longer as a result of any specific industry, however as it’s the suitable factor to do,” Jordan stated.

The total textual content of the ordinance is integrated underneath (obtain PDF):



WHEREAS, the Town of Fayetteville has an hobby in keeping up the general public protection and welfare of electorate and citizens of Fayetteville and its guests; and

WHEREAS, Ark. Code Ann. § 14-54-103(7) supplies that towns shall have the facility to forestall cruelty to animals; and

WHEREAS, the Humane Society of the US estimates that there are no less than 10,000 pet generators in the US, fewer than 3,000 of that are regulated via the US Division of Agriculture; and

WHEREAS, consistent with the Humane Society of the US, pet generators are top quantity canine breeding amenities that churn out doggies for benefit, ignoring the desires of the puppies and their moms; and

WHEREAS, consistent with the Humane Society of the US, pet generators usually promote thru retail puppy shops and nearly all of doggies offered in puppy shops are from pet generators; and

WHEREAS, present state and federal rules don’t adequately cope with the sale of pet and kitten mill canine and cats in retail puppy stores; and

WHEREAS, Petco and Petsmart, the Town’s biggest puppy provide shops, have company mandates in opposition to the sale of canine and cats and each paintings with native puppy rescues and shelters to permit puppy adoptions thru the ones organizations at their retailer places; and

WHEREAS, it’s within the hobby of the Town of Fayetteville to advertise and make sure humane approaches and requirements for animal disposition and possession via encouraging the adoption of rescue canine and cats.


Phase 1: That the Town Council of the Town of Fayetteville, Arkansas hereby amends § 92.04 via enacting a brand new subsection (C) as proven underneath:

“(C) It can be illegal for a puppy store to supply on the market or to show any canine, cat, pet, or kitten except bought from and in cooperation with the Fayetteville Animal Safe haven, a central authority or nonprofit animal refuge authorized via Fayetteville Animal Products and services, or a nonprofit animal rescue group authorized via Fayetteville Animal Products and services. Each puppy store providing on the market or exhibiting any canine, cat, pet, or kitten shall show a label declaring the identify and cope with of the group supplying stated animal at the animal’s cage.”

Phase 2: That the Town Council of the Town of Fayetteville, Arkansas hereby determines that this ordinance must change into efficient at once as a result of it’s going to assist save you the sale of ill animals from pet generators and different industrial breeding amenities by which the well being of the animals being bred is brushed aside, which is vital for the general public peace in addition to the well being and protection of Fayetteville citizens. Due to this fact, the Town Council hereby proclaims an emergency exists such that this ordinance shall change into efficient right away upon its passage and approval.

Flyer E-newsletter

The newest headlines from the Fayetteville Flyer, delivered directly in your inbox.